I wonder why humans have this desperate biological imperative to categorize everything into "good" and "bad." We do it with fruit, with weather, and especially with people. We see a person performing a set of repeatable actions and we slap a label on them like "reliable" or "efficient" because it's easier than admitting we're all just atoms vibrating in a state of perpetual chaos. I've spent three years being the "reliable" one. At home, I'm the one who remembers the 4:00 PM pediatric dosage for acetaminophen and exactly which pacifier has the right texture for a teething toddler. At the store, I'm the one who keeps the denim wall in perfect chronological order by wash and size. But something broke on Tuesday at 7:42 PM.
I was standing in Section 4—Menswear. There were exactly 18 navy blue Pima cotton polo shirts scattered across the display table. Someone had rummaged through them, probably looking for a Medium, and left the rest in a twisted heap that looked like a topographical map of a very depressing country. Usually, my hands just... go. It's a reflexive motor response. Fold, tuck, smooth, repeat. It's a way to quiet the noise in my head, the constant loop of "what am I doing with my life" and "did I forget to defrost the chicken." But I just stood there. I looked at my hands and they felt heavy, like they were made of lead or some other dense, non-reactive element.
I think we underestimate how much of our identity is just a series of performances we put on to satisfy the expectations of the collective. We act like "employees" or "parents" or "partners" because the alternative is a social vacuum that none of us are equipped to survive. I realized in that moment that I didn't want to fold the 19th shirt. I didn't want to fix the hanger that was facing the wrong way on the clearance rack. I just let it stay there—a size 14 floral dress hanging among the size 2s. It felt like a small act of sabotage against the version of me that everyone else seems to depend on.
My manager, Diane, walked by about ten minutes later. She's 52 and uses a very specific shade of fuchsia lipstick that always ends up on her front teeth. She stopped and looked at me—or rather, she looked at the version of me she’s constructed in her head. She said, "Thanks for staying late again, you're such a reliable team member, I don't know what we'd do without you." And I felt this sharp, localized pain in my chest, right near the sternum. It was a visceral manifestation of cognitive dissonance. She was praising a ghost. She was thanking a person who had stopped existing ten minutes prior, someone who was currently just a shell standing under 4000-Kelvin fluorescent lights.
I didn't say anything. I just nodded. I think that's the part that haunts me now, sitting here in the dark at 2:23 AM while the baby monitor hums with white noise. I accepted the praise for a lie. It’s like when you’re a kid and you realize your parents aren’t actually gods, they’re just people who are also scared of the dark. I feel like I’m a simulation of a human being. Being a stay-at-home parent for five years... it does something to your neural pathways. You become a service provider. You lose the ability to have a self that isn't defined by what you can do for someone else. You’re a dispenser of snacks, a folder of laundry, a "reliable team member."
I spent the rest of my shift just... drifting. I walked past a rack of circular-knit sweaters that were a total disaster—arms tangled, some on the floor—and I just kept walking. I watched a customer drop a silk scarf and kick it under the shoe display, and I felt nothing. No urge to correct the entropy. It’s strange how quickly the systems we build for ourselves can collapse when we stop believing in the merit of the work. We tell ourselves that these small orders matter—that the symmetry of a retail floor or the schedule of a household is what keeps the world turning—but it's just a collective hallucination we use to stave off the realization that we are fundamentally alone.
I’m looking at my husband sleeping next to me and I wonder if he sees the fraud too. Or if he’s just like Diane, seeing the "reliable" wife who keeps the house at a steady 71 degrees and makes sure the bills are paid on the 1st of every month. There’s a specific kind of isolation that comes from being seen but not perceived. It’s like I’m a piece of furniture that’s been moved two inches to the left—no one notices the change, they just feel a vague sense of unease when they walk through the room. I feel like I’m disappearing in plain sight and I don't know how to stop it.
I have 14 tabs open on my phone right now. One is a Wikipedia page for "Depersonalization-derealization disorder" and another is a job listing for a data entry position three towns over that pays $16 an hour. I don't even need the money that badly, we’re stable enough, but I just want to go somewhere where I don't have to be "reliable." I want to be a stranger. I want to be someone who doesn't have a history of folding sweaters or wiping noses. But I know that’s just another performance. We just trade one costume for another and call it "starting over" but the fabric is always the same.
The baby just made a sound—a soft, wet cough—and my body reacted before my brain did. I’m already halfway out of bed. The "reliable" one is back online. I hate her. I hate how efficient she is. I hate that she knows exactly where the thermometer is in the second drawer. I’m going to go into that room and I’m going to be exactly who they expect me to be, but inside, I’m still standing in Section 4, staring at those 18 messy navy blue shirts and wondering what would happen if I just... never fixed them. If I just let the whole world stay messy.
Share this thought
Does this resonate with you?